Welcome to Fat Jimmy’s Pizza
At Fat Jimmy's Pizza, located in Louisville, KY, the passion for quality pizza and community shines brightly. Established as a family-friendly establishment, it offers a delightful buffet featuring a diverse range of fresh pizzas, from classic pepperoni to unique creations like the Tito Pizza with bacon and banana peppers. Guests rave about the inviting atmosphere, where laughter fills the air, and the attentive staff ensure everyone feels at home. With in-house made tomato sauce and a selection of salads and appetizers, Fat Jimmy's Pizza creates memorable dining experiences. It’s a place where great food and warm smiles come together, leaving patrons satisfied and eager to return.
-
12216 Shelbyville Rd, Louisville, KY 40243 Hotline: (502) 244-2500
Welcome to the vibrant world of Fat Jimmy’s Pizza, a cherished gem nestled in the heart of Louisville, Kentucky, at 12216 Shelbyville Rd. This restaurant is not just about serving pizza; it embodies the joy of togetherness and mouthwatering flavors that leave a lasting impression. With a friendly team ready to welcome you, every dining experience here is infused with warmth and hospitality.
At Fat Jimmy’s, the menu is a delicious fusion of traditional and innovative pizza creations. The highlight is undoubtedly their Chicken Ranch Pizza, a creamy and flavorful masterpiece that has garnered rave reviews from guests like Robyn P., who described it as “The Best!” But the selection doesn't stop there; their buffet style offers an enticing variety, ensuring you never get bored. A nod to their impressive meat pizza and unique options like the Tito Pizza, complete with white sauce and bacon, caters to both adventurous tastes and classic palates alike.
- Appetizers: Start your meal off right with cheesy delights, from 10-inch Cheese Sticks to Hot Buttery Balls. These are not just starter dishes; they’re essentials that set the tone for a memorable meal.
- Salads: For those looking to balance their meals, the salad offerings—including fresh Caesar and hearty Grilled Chicken Salads—provide a satisfying contrast to the rich flavors of pizza.
- Beverages: Pair your meal with refreshing options like fresh brewed tea or a selection of bottled drinks to cleanse the palate between bites.
Customers enjoy the lively ambiance where laughter and conversations swirl around. Many have fond memories of celebration, whether it’s a family gathering or a special event like a quinceanera. The staff, like Emma, known for her attentive service and cheerful demeanor, add a personal touch that enhances the dining experience, making you feel at home.
Moreover, patrons can’t stop talking about the value and quality at Fat Jimmy’s Pizza. The buffet, priced at just $12, offers a feast of freshly made pizzas, pastas, and a limited salad bar, all ensuring that your cravings are thoroughly satisfied without breaking the bank. Guests like Katie L. have compared it favorably to national pizza chains, praising its higher quality and meticulous cleanliness.
In summary, Fat Jimmy’s Pizza is more than just a dining spot; it's a slice of community spirit. Whether indulging in their delectable pizzas, sharing hearty appetizers, or enjoying the warm atmosphere, you’re in for a treat that transcends the ordinary pizza experience. Don’t miss out on this beloved corner of Louisville—where every visit promises great food, great service, and a great time!
3/26/2025 Tonight we went to dinner with 11 Residents from Swan Pointe HOA. This was our 3rd year to come eat at Fat Jimmy's Pizza and I have to say, the pizza my husband had ordered for me was The Best! It was a Chicken Ranch Pizza. All of us chatted about our food. My husband really enjoyed the Alfredo Pasta and his favorite pizza was the Chicken Ranch. I gave him a piece of my pizza and as soon as he finished it, he went back to the buffet and they had baked a whole new Chicken Ranch pizza. He was so excited that he could have more pizza! Every one had at least one of the Sugar Balls. I have to say they were the best ever! The restaurant was almost filled tonight. It was such a happy place. There was a lot of talking at everyone's table but we were still able to hear each other. There was even a family celebrating their daughter's quinceanera. Emma was the cashier and she worked really hard tonight and always had a smile on her face. She took pizza orders, ran the cash register, cleared tables and made everyone feel welcomed to her place of work. It was a great night and we all left with full bellies and a smile on our faces. Robyn
Dat cheese is very drippy. Sauce was goated. Buffet style to keep it moving. Crew was sigma. The aura up here was high. Decent ambiance.
I ate jimmys pizza buffet for lunch today. I would rate this Buffett place above most pizza buffets that I have ever visited. The restaurant was well lit and clean and I we were pleasantly greeted as we arrived. This place offered a limited salad bar, pasta bar and numerous different pizzas. I only had the meats pizza and it was fresh, tasty and overall I would rate it as well above average. I would recommend this place for a family that wants several different styles of pizza. You will leave happily satisfied.
Have never been here before and I can say we will for sure be back. Came here for lunch Buffett and everything was "hot" and very good! We live in Indiana but when over this way again we will back. Great service and great food!
Great special! A 10" pizza with one topping is $6.99. They also have specials for 3 toppings and a drink or a 14". We easily ordered online and picked up our pizzas at their drive thru. This was a great price to get each person their own pizza. You can pick your crust option as well. We all enjoyed our dinner. We will be putting Fat Jimmy's back into the rotation.
Salad options were great, dressing was okay, they but it prepacked from a supplier. But still satisfying overall. Tomato Sauce is made in house, and has an interesting mix of herbs with a sweet aftertaste. I used it as a dipping sauce. Pizza was the star of the show! Pepperoni was very tasty. I loved the Tito Pizza, it has white base, bacon, bacon, banana peppers, and buffalo sauce. Food stations were clean, with constant fresh food. Staff was attentive, and friendly. Overall a great experience. Food was pretty good, and great deal for $12 buffet.
Wow wow wow. What a gem! My husband and I have nostalgic memories of a national pizza buffet brand which is now largely nonexistent. Fat Jimmy's is a similar concept but INFINITELY higher quality. We came on a busy weekend and every single table was bussed and cleaned within minutes of the customers' departure. Not only that, every single party was told "thanks for coming, have a great day!" on their way out! I was blown away by the friendliness off the staff. I wish we lived in the Louisville area just to become a regular of this establishment. Food was excellent, salad options were fresh, veggie options plentiful, everything was remarkably clean, and obviously it was excellent value! 10 stars , can't wait to return.